Peacock’s new true crime series Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy redefines the genre by blending meticulous research with empathetic storytelling. Rather than sensationalizing the notorious serial killer’s crimes, the four-part documentary offers a thoughtful examination of the social forces, investigative breakthroughs, and human consequences surrounding the Gacy case.
Series Overview
Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy chronicles the horrific crimes of John Wayne Gacy, who murdered at least 33 young men in the 1970s. The series interweaves archival footage, rare police recordings, and interviews with surviving family members, investigators, and journalists, crafting a comprehensive narrative that balances procedural detail with personal testimony.
A Thoughtful Approach
Unlike typical true crime fare, the documentary refrains from exploiting graphic details for shock value. Instead, it contextualizes Gacy’s crimes within the era’s social climate—examining law enforcement limitations, community stigma, and the vulnerability of Gacy’s victims. By foregrounding survivor stories and expert insights, the series fosters empathy and critical reflection rather than mere morbid curiosity.
Production & Direction
Directed by Oscar-nominated filmmaker Elizabeth Chai Vasarhelyi and produced by Blumhouse Television in partnership with Peacock Originals, the series employs a restrained visual style. Cinematographer Daniel Grant uses muted color palettes and static interviews to maintain a respectful tone. The score by Todd Bryanton underscores emotional beats without overwhelming the narrative.
Reception & Impact
The series has earned praise for its sensitivity and depth, garnering a 92% critics rating on Rotten Tomatoes and sparking discussions about ethical storytelling in true crime. Viewers have commended its focus on victims’ families and its critique of systemic failures. Psychologists and sociologists have cited the series in debates over criminal justice reform and media responsibility.
Where to Watch
All four episodes of Devil in Disguise: John Wayne Gacy are available exclusively on Peacock Premium. New subscribers can access the series immediately, while existing Peacock members with a Premium subscription can stream at no additional cost. The series is also available for offline download within the Peacock app.
Sources: Peacock Originals press release, IMDb, Variety, Rotten Tomatoes
